Alternative
Valuation
Methods.
When the transaction value cannot be used, EU customs law provides a structured sequence of alternative methods to determine the customs value of imported goods.
Understand identical and similar goods, the deductive and computed value methods, and the fallback method — including the mandatory order of application, the available flexibility and the evidence needed to support a valuation.
Deductive and computed value may be applied in reverse order at the declarant’s request, subject to the applicable rules.
Methods applied in the prescribed order
Objective and supportable valuation data
Defined reversal and fallback provisions
A Legal Hierarchy. Not a Choice of Convenience.
The Union Customs Code establishes transaction value as the primary basis for determining the customs value of imported goods. Where that value cannot be determined under Article 70, Article 74 provides a structured sequence of secondary valuation methods.
Transaction Value Remains the Starting Point.
Article 70 UCC establishes the transaction value method, based on the price actually paid or payable for goods sold for export to the customs territory of the Union, subject to the relevant legal conditions and adjustments.
Article 74 applies where the customs value cannot be determined under Article 70. It does not provide an alternative merely because another method appears simpler, more favourable or commercially preferable.
The Five Secondary Valuation Methods
Article 74(2) establishes four methods to be considered in sequence. Article 74(3) provides the fallback method where the customs value cannot be determined under Article 74(2).
Transaction Value of Identical Goods
A transaction value previously accepted for identical goods sold for export to the Union and exported at or about the same time as the goods being valued, subject to the applicable comparison and adjustment rules.
Transaction Value of Similar Goods
A transaction value previously accepted for similar goods sold for export to the Union and exported at or about the same time, taking account of the relevant legal requirements and permitted adjustments.
Deductive Value
A method based on the relevant unit price at which imported goods, or identical or similar imported goods, are sold in the Union, with the deductions required by the applicable rules.
Computed Value
A method based on specified production costs, an appropriate amount for profit and general expenses, and the relevant transport and related costs identified in the legislation.
Permitted reversal: Under Article 74(2) UCC, the order of the deductive and computed value methods is reversed if the declarant requests it. This exception does not permit the identical or similar goods methods to be skipped.
Fallback Method
Where the customs value cannot be determined under Article 74(2), it is determined using reasonable means consistent with the principles and general provisions of the applicable international valuation framework and EU customs valuation rules, on the basis of data available in the Union.
When Can Customs Move to the Next Method?
The prescribed sequence requires an assessment of whether a value can be established under the preceding method, applying the relevant legal criteria and available evidence.
Establish Why Article 70 Cannot Be Used
Identify the relevant legal or factual reason why the transaction value cannot be determined. A missing invoice alone does not automatically resolve the legal valuation question.
Assess Each Applicable Method in Order
Examine whether a suitable customs value can be determined under the current method before proceeding to the next, taking account of the permitted reversal between Article 74(2)(c) and (d).
Use Legally Suitable Supporting Data
Comparable transactions, Union sales and production information must satisfy the requirements of the method concerned. The availability of a number does not necessarily make it an acceptable customs valuation basis.
Record the Basis of the Determination
Retain the relevant evidence, calculations and reasons supporting the method used. Where a method cannot determine the value, document the factual basis for moving to the next method.
What the Legal Hierarchy Does Not Permit
Choosing the Lowest Available Value
The applicable method is determined by the legal sequence, not by which calculation produces the lowest duty.
Skipping Directly to the Fallback Method
Article 74(3) applies only when the customs value cannot be determined under Article 74(2).
Using Any Comparable Market Price
Identical and similar goods methods require qualifying transaction values and legally relevant comparability, not arbitrary catalogue prices.
Treating the Reversal as General Flexibility
The declarant’s request concerns the order of the deductive and computed value methods only.
First Determine the Applicable Method. Then Determine the Customs Value.
A defensible customs valuation starts with the legal method, not a preferred commercial amount. The supporting data and calculations must follow the requirements of that method.
Regulation (EU) No 952/2013, Articles 70 and 74. Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2015/2447, Articles 141–144, provides further rules for secondary customs valuation methods.
Identical & Similar Goods. Comparable Does Not Mean Interchangeable.
Articles 74(2)(a) and 74(2)(b) of the Union Customs Code use transaction values of other imported goods as a basis for valuation. Their application depends on legally qualifying comparisons, not simply on finding products with similar prices.
Identical Goods
Goods that are the same in all relevant respects, including physical characteristics, quality and reputation.
Minor differences in appearance do not necessarily prevent goods from being treated as identical where they otherwise satisfy the legal definition.
Two shipments of the same model of industrial sensor, manufactured by the same producer in the same country, with matching technical specifications and quality.
Similar Goods
Goods that are not alike in all respects but have like characteristics and component materials, enabling them to perform the same functions and be commercially interchangeable.
Quality, reputation and the existence of a trademark are among the factors considered when determining similarity.
Two industrial sensors with comparable specifications and functions, produced in the same country, where the evidence supports commercial interchangeability despite differences in model or design.
What Makes a Comparison Legally Suitable?
The comparison must satisfy the relevant requirements of the customs valuation rules. Product similarity alone is insufficient.
Country of Production
Identical and similar goods must meet the relevant same-country production requirement. A product manufactured elsewhere cannot automatically be treated as an eligible comparator.
Relevant Export Timing
The comparator goods must have been exported at or about the same time as the goods being valued, as required by the applicable valuation provisions.
Transaction Value Basis
The method relies on an eligible transaction value determined under Article 70 UCC. A catalogue price, supplier quotation or unsupported estimate is not equivalent.
Commercial Level & Quantity
Comparisons should account for differences in commercial level and quantities where the legislation permits and the adjustment can be substantiated.
Producer & Product Characteristics
The identity of the producer and the goods’ technical and commercial characteristics matter. The rules establish conditions for considering goods produced by another producer.
Evidence-Based Adjustments
Adjustments for qualifying differences must be supported by demonstrated evidence. They cannot be arbitrary percentages chosen to achieve a desired customs value.
Identical vs Similar Goods — At a Glance
| Assessment factor | Identical goods | Similar goods |
|---|---|---|
| Physical characteristics | Same in all relevant respects | Like characteristics; differences permitted |
| Quality and reputation | Relevant to identity | Relevant to commercial similarity |
| Function | Same goods and function | Same functions and commercial interchangeability |
| Production country | Same country required | Same country required |
| Export timing | At or about the same time | At or about the same time |
| Position in hierarchy | First secondary method | Second secondary method |
| Valuation basis | Qualifying transaction value | Qualifying transaction value |
Commercial Level, Quantity & Transport Differences
Article 141 of Implementing Regulation (EU) 2015/2447 provides rules for using the transaction value of identical or similar goods, including adjustments where the conditions are satisfied.
Commercial Level
A wholesale transaction and a retail transaction may involve different pricing structures. Relevant adjustments must be supported by evidence demonstrating their reasonableness and accuracy.
Quantity Differences
An eligible transaction for 10,000 units may not have the same unit price as a shipment of 500 units. A quantity adjustment requires reliable supporting evidence.
Transport-Related Differences
Where applicable, significant differences in transport-related costs arising from differences in distance or mode of transport must be addressed under the relevant rules.
Identical Goods — A Quantity Adjustment
The following example is simplified and assumes the comparison satisfies all other applicable legal requirements.
Same Product. Different Order Size.
Adjusted value per unit
Similar Goods — Commercial Interchangeability
Two Industrial Components
Component A
Imported industrial component, with no qualifying identical-goods transaction value available.
Component B
Component produced in the same country, with comparable characteristics and evidence of commercial interchangeability.
Component B may provide a basis for the similar-goods method if the applicable legal criteria are met, a qualifying transaction value exists, and any required adjustments can be substantiated.
Functional resemblance alone does not establish an acceptable similar-goods customs value.
What If Several Suitable Transaction Values Exist?
The Lowest Qualifying Value Rule
Under Article 141 IA, where more than one transaction value of identical or similar goods is found in accordance with the applicable rules, the lowest of those values is used to determine the customs value.
This is not permission to search indiscriminately for the lowest market price. The values must first qualify under the relevant method.
Assumes all three are legally qualifying values expressed on a comparable per-unit basis.
Evidence to Support the Comparison
A defensible comparison requires records establishing both the eligibility of the comparator and the reliability of any adjustments.
Technical characteristics, materials, models, quality and commercial identity.
Country of production, producer identity and relevant manufacturing details.
Evidence of qualifying transaction values and relevant export timing.
Sales level, order quantity, pricing conditions and contractual differences.
Reliable data supporting quantity, commercial level and relevant cost adjustments.
Reasoned selection of the method and explanation of the resulting customs value.
A Similar Product Is Not Necessarily a Valid Customs Comparator.
The method requires a legally qualifying transaction value, appropriate comparability and evidence-based adjustments. If no value can be determined using identical or similar goods, the valuation sequence continues under Article 74(2).
Regulation (EU) No 952/2013, Article 74(2)(a)–(b). Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2015/2447, Article 141. Relevant definitions are provided by the applicable customs valuation legislation.
Deductive & Computed Value. Two Different Routes to a Customs Value.
Where a customs value cannot be determined using qualifying transactions involving identical or similar goods, the valuation sequence turns to two fundamentally different approaches: one works backwards from sales in the Union; the other builds the value from production costs and other prescribed elements.
Deductive Value
Starts from a qualifying unit price at which the imported goods, or identical or similar imported goods, are sold in the Union to unrelated buyers.
Computed Value
Builds the customs value using the specified costs of producing the imported goods, an appropriate amount for profit and general expenses, and the applicable Article 71(1)(e) elements.
Deductive Value: Working Backwards from Union Sales
The deductive method uses the relevant unit price at which the greatest aggregate quantity of qualifying goods is sold to unrelated persons in the Union, applying the timing and other conditions established by Article 142 of Implementing Regulation (EU) 2015/2447.
Identify Qualifying Sales
Establish eligible sales of the imported goods or identical or similar imported goods in the Union, including the relevant timing and buyer relationship conditions.
Determine the Relevant Unit Price
Identify the unit price at which the greatest aggregate quantity is sold, rather than automatically selecting the highest, lowest or average selling price.
Apply Prescribed Deductions
Deduct the amounts specified by the legal rules, including qualifying commissions or profit and general expenses, relevant Union transport costs, and applicable import duties and taxes.
Substantiate the Result
Retain sales records, quantity calculations, supporting financial information and evidence for each deduction used.
Deductive Value: Main Deduction Categories
Commissions or Profit & General Expenses
The commissions usually paid or agreed to be paid, or the additions usually made for profit and general expenses, in connection with qualifying Union sales of imported goods of the same class or kind.
Union Transport & Insurance
Usual transport and insurance costs and associated costs incurred within the customs territory of the Union, in accordance with the applicable rules.
Import Duties & Other Union Taxes
Customs duties and other taxes payable in the Union by reason of importation or sale of the goods, as provided by the deductive valuation rules.
Deductive Value — Numerical Calculation
Simplified example assuming a qualifying Union selling price and documented deductions. Amounts are illustrative, not statutory percentages.
From Selling Price to Customs Value
Per imported unit
ILLUSTRATIVE SHIPMENT 500 unitsComputed Value: Building the Value from Production Data
Computed value requires a reliable calculation of the prescribed cost and expense elements. In practice, obtaining sufficiently detailed and verifiable information from the producer can be a major obstacle.
Materials & Fabrication
The cost or value of materials and fabrication or other processing employed in producing the imported goods, determined under the applicable rules.
Profit & General Expenses
An amount equal to that usually reflected in sales of goods of the same class or kind as the goods being valued, made by producers in the country of exportation for export to the Union.
Relevant Article 71(1)(e) Elements
The cost or value of the applicable transport, loading, handling and insurance elements specified in Article 71(1)(e) UCC.
Computed Value — Numerical Calculation
The example assumes that all figures are supported by reliable producer records and meet the legal requirements.
From Production Costs to Customs Value
Per imported unit
ILLUSTRATIVE SHIPMENT 500 unitsCan the Declarant Reverse the Order?
Article 74(2) UCC provides for reversal of the order of points (c) and (d) if the declarant requests it. The exception does not allow the earlier identical-goods and similar-goods methods to be bypassed, nor does it remove the substantive requirements of either method.
Which Information Does Each Method Require?
| Factor | Deductive value | Computed value |
|---|---|---|
| Starting information | Qualifying sales in the Union | Production and cost records |
| Calculation direction | Works backwards from selling price | Builds upwards from cost elements |
| Key commercial evidence | Sales quantities, prices and deductions | Producer accounts and relevant expense data |
| Common practical difficulty | Establishing the correct unit price and deductions | Obtaining reliable producer information |
| Relevant implementing rule | Article 142 IA | Article 143 IA |
| Order of application | Normally third secondary method | Normally fourth secondary method |
What Should the Importer Be Able to Demonstrate?
Why the preceding valuation methods could not determine the customs value.
Where the Union selling prices or producer cost information originated.
A reproducible calculation identifying every relevant component and adjustment.
Sales records, accounts, cost statements and evidence supporting the amounts used.
Evidence that the declarant requested the permitted reversal of methods.
The resulting customs value and the reasoning supporting its determination.
Deductive Value Starts with Sales. Computed Value Starts with Production.
Both methods require legally suitable evidence and prescribed calculations. Neither permits a customs value to be constructed from unsupported assumptions or convenient estimates.
Regulation (EU) No 952/2013, Article 74(2)(c)–(d). Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2015/2447, Articles 142 and 143.
The Fallback Method. Reasonable Means. Defined Legal Boundaries.
The fallback method is the final stage of the customs valuation hierarchy. It applies where the customs value cannot be determined under Article 70 or the secondary methods in Article 74(2) of the Union Customs Code. Its flexibility is real, but it is not unlimited.
Reasonable Means, Not Arbitrary Values.
Article 74(3) requires customs value to be determined using reasonable means consistent with the principles and general provisions of the relevant international customs valuation framework and the Union Customs Code.
The determination must be based on data available in the customs territory of the Union. Article 144 of Implementing Regulation (EU) 2015/2447 provides further rules for applying the fallback method.
What Does the Fallback Method Actually Allow?
Article 144 permits reasonable flexibility in applying the valuation methods established by Articles 70 and 74(2), subject to the principles and limitations governing customs valuation.
Adaptation of Earlier Methods
The starting point remains the existing valuation framework. A method that cannot be applied strictly may, where legally appropriate, be applied with reasonable flexibility under Article 144.
Reasonable Use of Available Data
The assessment may use suitable information available in the Union, provided the data supports a reasoned valuation consistent with the governing legal principles.
Relaxation of Certain Requirements
Reasonable flexibility may concern aspects of the preceding methods that prevent their strict application. It does not authorise the removal of essential legal safeguards.
Documented Valuation Reasoning
The chosen approach should explain which earlier method provides its basis, why flexibility is necessary and how the resulting amount was determined.
Adjusting a Recognised Method
Using an earlier valuation method as the starting point, with justified flexibility and suitable supporting data.
Potentially permissibleInventing a Convenient Amount
Selecting an unsupported price, applying an unexplained percentage or adopting a value solely because it appears reasonable.
Not permissibleValuation Bases That Cannot Be Used
The fallback method cannot rely on the prohibited valuation bases identified by Article 144 of Implementing Regulation (EU) 2015/2447.
Union Selling Price of Goods Produced in the Union
The selling price in the Union of goods produced in the Union cannot serve as the customs value of imported goods under the fallback method.
Automatically Choosing the Higher of Two Values
A system that provides for acceptance of the higher of two alternative values is expressly prohibited.
Domestic Market Price in the Country of Exportation
The price of goods on the domestic market of the country of exportation is not an acceptable fallback valuation basis.
Unapproved Production Cost Substitutes
The cost of production cannot be used as a substitute valuation basis other than through computed values determined in accordance with the relevant legal requirements.
Prices for Export to a Third Country
Prices of goods for export to a country outside the customs territory of the Union cannot be used as the fallback valuation basis.
Minimum Customs Values
A fixed minimum customs value cannot replace the legally required valuation determination.
Arbitrary or Fictitious Values
Unsupported, invented or purely discretionary values are prohibited, even where they appear commercially plausible.
Three Examples of Fallback Valuation Decisions
These scenarios illustrate the legal reasoning. They are not automatic authorisations to apply a particular valuation method.
An Earlier Comparable Transaction
No qualifying transaction value of identical or similar goods is available within the strict requirements of Article 141. The importer has reliable information about a comparable transaction outside those strict conditions.
Assess whether reasonable flexibility under Article 144 permits the information to support a valuation derived from an earlier method. The timing, comparability and adjustments must be justified.
A Customs Value Based on a Minimum Price List
A reference list indicates that a product should have a customs value of at least €100 per unit. The importer has no supporting valuation calculation.
A minimum customs value is expressly prohibited as a fallback basis. A reference price may prompt further examination, but it does not automatically establish customs value.
Choosing an Arbitrary Percentage of Retail Price
An importer proposes declaring customs value at 40% of the retail price because this percentage is commonly used in its internal commercial calculations.
An unexplained percentage is not a recognised valuation method. The importer must establish a legally defensible basis supported by appropriate data.
A Defensible Fallback Valuation Process
Document the Failure of Earlier Methods
Record why Article 70 and each relevant Article 74(2) method cannot determine the customs value.
Identify the Earlier Method Used as a Reference
Determine which established valuation approach offers a suitable starting point for reasonable flexibility.
Verify Data and Legal Limitations
Confirm that the supporting data is suitable and that the proposed calculation does not rely on a prohibited valuation basis.
Calculate and Retain Supporting Evidence
Preserve the source data, assumptions, adjustments and reproducible calculation supporting the value.
Explain the Valuation to Customs
Provide a clear explanation of the legal method, the reason for flexibility and the basis of the resulting customs value.
Evidence Worth Retaining
Reasons why the primary and preceding secondary methods could not determine the value.
Source, date and reliability of the information used for the calculation.
Product, timing, commercial and other relevant differences.
Explanation and evidence supporting each adjustment to the source information.
Confirmation that no prohibited valuation basis was used.
A clear, reproducible calculation and any relevant correspondence with customs authorities.
Customs risk indicators, statistical values, commercial databases and price references may be relevant to an examination of a declared value. Their existence alone does not replace the legal valuation methods or justify an arbitrary assessment.
Flexibility Is Permitted. Arbitrariness Is Not.
The fallback method remains anchored to the established customs valuation framework. A defensible result requires suitable data, reasoned adjustments and compliance with the express legal prohibitions.
Regulation (EU) No 952/2013, Article 74(3). Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2015/2447, Article 144.
Alternative Valuation Methods. Frequently Asked Questions.
Understanding when and how to move beyond transaction value is essential for defensible customs declarations. These answers address the most common questions about the valuation hierarchy, comparative methods, deductive and computed value, and the fallback method.
01 When must alternative customs valuation methods be used?
Alternative methods apply when customs value cannot be determined under Article 70 UCC, which establishes the primary transaction value method. The reasons for not using transaction value must be examined and documented before proceeding through Article 74.
A lower value produced by an alternative method is not, by itself, a reason to abandon a valid transaction value.
02 Can an importer choose whichever valuation method gives the lowest result?
No. The methods follow a mandatory sequence. The next method is considered only when the customs value cannot be determined under the preceding method.
Article 74(2) permits reversal of the order of deductive and computed value at the declarant’s request. This does not create a general right to choose freely between valuation methods.
03 What is the difference between identical and similar goods?
Identical goods are the same in all relevant respects, including physical characteristics, quality and reputation, subject to the applicable legal definition.
Similar goods need not be identical. They must have like characteristics and component materials, perform the same functions and be commercially interchangeable. Country of production, export timing and other legal conditions also matter.
04 Can a supplier quotation be used as an identical-goods transaction value?
A quotation is not automatically a qualifying transaction value. The identical-goods and similar-goods methods rely on eligible transaction values determined under the applicable customs valuation rules.
Quotations and other commercial information may have an evidential role in appropriate circumstances, but they cannot simply replace the required transaction value under Articles 74(2)(a) or (b).
05 How are differences in quantity or commercial level treated?
Article 141 IA provides for the use of eligible comparison transactions and relevant adjustments. Differences in commercial level and quantity may require adjustments supported by demonstrated evidence.
An arbitrary percentage is not sufficient. The adjustment must be reasonable, accurate and substantiated by appropriate information.
06 What does the greatest aggregate quantity mean in deductive valuation?
The deductive method uses the qualifying unit price at which the greatest aggregate quantity of the relevant goods is sold to unrelated buyers in the Union, subject to the applicable conditions.
This is not necessarily the highest selling price, the lowest selling price or an arithmetic average of all sales. Sales quantities and prices must be examined together.
07 Can deductive value be used if the imported goods are sold after processing?
The legislation contains provisions addressing goods sold after further processing, subject to the relevant conditions and an appropriate allowance for the value added by that processing.
This is not a general permission to use any finished-product selling price. The applicable rules, including Article 142 IA, must be examined before relying on such sales.
08 Does computed value mean manufacturing cost plus a standard percentage?
No. Computed value is based on the legally prescribed production costs, profit and general expenses, and relevant Article 71(1)(e) elements.
The profit and general expenses component must meet the applicable criteria. There is no universal customs valuation markup that can simply be applied to every product.
09 What happens if the foreign manufacturer refuses to provide cost information?
A lack of reliable producer information may prevent computed value from being determined. The importer should document the information requested, what is unavailable and why the method cannot be applied.
If no customs value can be determined under the applicable preceding methods, the valuation sequence may proceed to Article 74(3).
10 Can customs authorities impose a minimum customs value under the fallback method?
Minimum customs values are expressly prohibited as a basis for determining customs value under Article 144 IA.
Reference prices or risk indicators may lead customs authorities to examine a declaration, but they do not automatically establish the legally correct customs value.
11 Can the fallback method use information from earlier valuation methods?
Yes. Article 144 IA allows reasonable flexibility in applying the methods established by Articles 70 and 74(2). This can make information derived from an earlier method relevant to a fallback assessment.
The approach must remain consistent with the governing valuation principles, use suitable data and avoid expressly prohibited valuation bases.
12 What documents should support an alternative customs valuation?
The evidence depends on the method. It may include purchase and sales contracts, import records, comparator transactions, product specifications, sales data, producer cost statements, financial records and adjustment calculations.
A written explanation of why earlier methods could not be applied, together with a reproducible valuation calculation, is particularly important for demonstrating the basis of the declaration.
Six Methods. One Legal Sequence.
Transaction value is the primary method. The remaining methods apply in the prescribed order when a value cannot be determined under the preceding method.
Official European Union Legislation
Use the consolidated legislation and applicable amendments when examining a specific customs valuation case.
Union Customs Code
Article 70 — Transaction value. Article 74 — Secondary methods of customs valuation.
View official legislation ↗UCC Implementing Regulation
Articles 141–144 — Identical and similar goods, deductive value, computed value and fallback valuation.
View official legislation ↗UCC Delegated Regulation
Supplementary customs rules and definitions relevant to the wider customs framework.
View official legislation ↗Related Customs Explorer Guides
Continue with the connected topics that explain how transaction value is determined, adjusted and supported in practice.
The Method Matters. So Does the Evidence.
Customs valuation is not a choice between convenient prices. It is a structured legal determination supported by commercial information, appropriate calculations and a documented method of assessment.
This guide provides general educational information about EU customs valuation. The correct method and customs value depend on the specific transaction, available evidence, applicable legislation and relevant customs decisions. Consult official legal sources and the competent customs authorities when assessing individual cases.